Whiny white liberal guilt alert from Michael Tomasky and Yglesias outraged that someone who is getting taxed out of his ass
would question it. A WSJ op-ed from a Mike Donahue asks why the hell am I paying so much damn tax and you still want more
blood from the stone.I'm in the 32% federal and 10% state income tax brackets. I pay a 1.2% property tax on very expensive California real estate. I am subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax. I am self-employed and subject to a 15% payroll tax on the first $100,000 in income and an 8.75% state sales tax. If I have a gain from investing, I pay a minimum of 15% federal and 10% state tax but can only write off $3,000 per year if I lose.
And now the government wants me to pay more?
As a child I mowed lawns, shoveled snow, had a paper route, sold sandwiches at school, and cut up dead trees and split them for firewood to sell during spring break. I have worked every summer since I turned 14. I took out student loans for college and worked 35 hours a week, at night, to pay for the rest...
...Why then does the government feel so entitled to take my money and give it to others? Why should I have to carry so many people on my back? Call me cruel. I don't care. I give to whom I choose—but since so much is confiscated (and wasted in the process) I have little left I wish to give...
...Life is hard. You learn when you fail and you make changes when things hurt. Why then is the liberal agenda trying to make sure nobody feels any pain? And why does the government feel so entitled to steal from many in order to give it to others.
This is just pure selfishness via Tomasky.
The narcissism of these people astonishes me, and I'm sorry to say it, but this selfishness is in fact a central part of the conservative world view. I got mine. Why can't everybody be like me? The completely inability to step outside one's own skin and see the world through other eyes is mind-bending.
Obviously, there are people who work hard, and there are people who don't. But that's one of many factors, as Matt's vignette suggests, that enable people to become high earners. Loads of people work awfully hard for $40,000. Maybe Donahue should trade places with them for a few days if he doesn't think so.
I also like the way he doesn't specify either what he makes or what precise confiscatory governmental grab he's referring to. Since the only things on the table right now are aimed at households above $250,000, I'm guessing he falls in that category but doesn't want to come out and admit it, at which point a percentage of his sympathy vote, even among Journal readers, would deplete.
In the 33% bracket, he would seem to live in a household between $209,251 and $373,650.
I am lucky to be a fairly high earner. I wrote a check to the IRS this week, and I wrote it happily. Taxes pay for my security, and they clean the air and clean the rivers and invest in innovation and -- yes -- they help people who could use a hand up who were born into less fortunate circumstances than I was (in historical terms, being born white and male to a semi-upper-middle-class family in the United States of America in 1960 is about as lucky as an aborning human soul can get). And they pay for a hundred other things that I could not do, services I could not perform, by myself. It's really a bargain when you think about it, if you can think beyond your own selfish wants and needs for five seconds.
Here is the white liberal guilt on display for all to mock. Liberals cannot fathom people who are working hard to make something of themselves as they push themselves up the income ladder why they are being used like whores while the government plays the pimp taking their earnings.
The guy is a "Henry" (high earners, not rich yet) and points out that social mobility depends on making a living and earning more money. You can't move up if the government and welfare supporters like Tomasky demand you put more and more anchors around your waist as you climb up.
The issue is not walking in other people's boots or those who make $40,000 work hard but the systematic demonizing and taking from those who are moving up or moved up the income ladder.
The fact is we have gotten to the point where 47% of the people in the country don't pay Federal Income Tax. Taxes for everyone is adding up and they cannot see where its going beyond the obvious services(Police/Fire). More policies that take from those who produce in this country to give to those deemed victims create a bigger pool of parasites.
For liberals that is great. No liberal party is in or stays in power without getting people hooked on government handouts and demonizing who they feel have earned too much. That is why liberals always change the subject by saying how mean and selfish you people are to others "less fortunate."
This is where the race or class card comes out because the more people who feel less guilty about their hard work has earned them their money, the more people who will start to question policies that simply do not work.